Whynotwin11

WhyNotWin11 vs PC Health Check: which checker to use

A fair comparison of the independent WhyNotWin11 and Microsoft's PC Health Check app, and when each one is the better choice.

  • Updated
  • Checked against WhyNotWin11 2.7.0.0
Feature image for the guide: WhyNotWin11 vs PC Health Check: which checker to use

If you want to know whether a PC can run Windows 11, two free tools come up again and again: Microsoft's PC Health Check app and the independent, open-source WhyNotWin11. Both read the same Windows 11 requirements, yet they present the answer very differently, and each has situations where it is the better choice.

This guide compares the two fairly: who makes them, what they check, how they show results, how they handle technicians' needs, and what to do when they disagree. It refers to WhyNotWin11 2.7.0.0 and the current PC Health Check app.

The two tools in brief

PC Health Check

PC Health Check is Microsoft's own app for Windows 10 PCs. Besides other health information, it includes a Windows 11 eligibility check: you select Check now, and the app reports either that the PC meets the requirements or that "This PC can't run Windows 11", with the reason.

WhyNotWin11

WhyNotWin11 is a free, portable utility by independent developer Robert C. Maehl, released under the LGPL-3.0 licence. It runs eleven checks and shows each one on its own line, with the value it detected and an icon and colour for the result.

Side-by-side comparison

FeatureWhyNotWin11PC Health Check
MakerRobert C. Maehl (independent)Microsoft
LicenceOpen source, LGPL-3.0Closed source, free
InstallationNone, single portable .exeInstalled app
Result formatEleven lines, each with detected valueOverall verdict with the reason for failures
Graphics (DirectX 12 / WDDM 2)CheckedNot checked — Microsoft states the app does not check graphics or display
Command line and silent modeYesNo
Export to CSV, TSV or TXTYesNo
Windows PE supportYes, since 2.7.0.0Not documented
Feature-update check on Windows 11Yes, with /fuonlyNot its purpose
Code-signedNo (2.7.0.0)Yes
Official Microsoft verdictNoYes

How each tool presents results

PC Health Check: the verdict first

PC Health Check is designed for home users who want a clear answer. When a PC passes, it says so. When it fails, it shows a dialog such as "This PC can't run Windows 11" and names the issue — for example that the processor is not supported, or that TPM 2.0 is a requirement and should be checked. You can expand the results to see which requirements passed.

WhyNotWin11: the details first

WhyNotWin11 assumes you want to understand and fix the problem. Every requirement gets its own row with the detected value, such as "Legacy", "GPT Not Detected" or "TPM 2 Detected". That makes it easy to see when several failures share one cause — for example, Legacy boot, an MBR disk and missing Secure Boot all appearing together.

What each tool checks

Both tools test the core Windows 11 requirements: a supported 64-bit processor with at least two cores at 1 GHz, 4 GB of RAM, 64 GB of storage, UEFI and Secure Boot capability, and TPM 2.0.

The main difference is graphics. WhyNotWin11 tests DirectX 12 compatibility and the WDDM 2.0 driver model. Microsoft notes that PC Health Check does not check graphics or display, because most compatible devices meet those requirements.

Strengths of PC Health Check

  • It is Microsoft's answer. The eligibility rules come from the same company that decides who receives Windows 11 through Windows Update.
  • It is signed and familiar. It installs like other Microsoft apps without SmartScreen warnings.
  • It is simple. For a home user who wants a yes or no and a hint, it does the job.
  • It does more than one thing. The app also shows other PC health information such as storage and start-up time.

Strengths of WhyNotWin11

  • Detail. Eleven separate results with detected values make troubleshooting faster.
  • Graphics included. It checks the DirectX and WDDM requirement that PC Health Check skips.
  • Portable. Nothing is installed; run it from a USB stick on many PCs.
  • Scriptable. /silent, /export, /skip and /extras support inventories and automation.
  • Windows PE. Technicians can check hardware before an operating system is installed.
  • Feature-update checks. On Windows 11 PCs, /fuonly reads Windows' own feature-update compatibility indicators.
  • Transparent. The source code is public, so anyone can see exactly how each check works.

Limitations to keep in mind

PC Health Check

  • No command line or export, so it does not scale to many PCs.
  • Requires installation on each machine.
  • Does not cover graphics.
  • Shows less detail about why a requirement failed.

WhyNotWin11

  • Not code-signed in version 2.7.0.0, so SmartScreen and some antivirus tools may warn. Verify the SHA-256 before running it.
  • Not an official verdict; Windows Update makes the final decision.
  • Windows only; Wine is unsupported after version 2.3.0.5.
  • Reports problems but does not change any setting for you.

Which one should you use?

Choose PC Health Check when

  • you want Microsoft's own answer;
  • you prefer a signed app from Microsoft;
  • you are checking a single home PC and a short reason is enough;
  • your organisation standardises on Microsoft tools.

Choose WhyNotWin11 when

  • you need to know exactly which requirement failed before changing firmware settings;
  • you want the graphics requirement included;
  • you check several PCs and need silent runs and reports;
  • you work in Windows PE before installing Windows;
  • you want to check feature-update compatibility on a Windows 11 PC.

Use both when

You are about to change firmware settings or buy hardware. Run WhyNotWin11 to find the exact gaps, make your changes, then confirm with PC Health Check that Microsoft's check agrees.

When the two tools disagree

Occasional differences happen. These are the usual reasons.

DifferenceLikely causeWhat to do
TPM passes in one, fails in the otherOne tool ran without administrator rights or before a restartRestart, run WhyNotWin11 as administrator, re-run PC Health Check
Processor passes in WhyNotWin11, fails in PC Health CheckLists updated at different timesTreat Microsoft's list as the reference for Windows Update
Processor fails in WhyNotWin11, passes in PC Health CheckWhyNotWin11 offline or an old buildConnect to the internet and use the latest WhyNotWin11
Graphics fails only in WhyNotWin11PC Health Check does not test graphicsFix the driver; see the DirectX and WDDM requirement
Secure Boot results differDifferent interpretation of capable versus enabledCheck msinfo32's Secure Boot State and BIOS Mode

Windows Update has the final say

Even when both tools pass, Windows Update may take some time to offer Windows 11. WhyNotWin11's own message notes that Windows Update may take up to 30 days to agree with a passing result, and that the Windows Installation Assistant can be used instead.

Other alternatives

  • Microsoft's Hardware Readiness script (HardwareReadiness.ps1) is a PowerShell script for administrators. It returns a machine-readable result of capable, not capable or undetermined, and is published under the MIT licence.
  • Win11SysCheck is an older open-source console tool by mq1n under GPL-3.0. Its repository is archived and its last release dates from 2021.

Running each tool, step by step

PC Health Check

  1. Install PC Health Check from Microsoft.
  2. Open the app from the Start menu.
  3. In the Windows 11 section, select Check now.
  4. Read the result. If the PC fails, the dialog names the problem, such as an unsupported processor or a TPM that needs to be enabled.
  5. Expand the full results to see which requirements passed.

WhyNotWin11

  1. Download the correct build and verify its SHA-256.
  2. Run WhyNotWin11.exe and accept the User Account Control prompt.
  3. Read the summary message and all eleven lines.
  4. Use the information buttons for an explanation of each requirement.
  5. Export the results if you need a record.

Scenarios and recommendations

ScenarioBest toolWhy
Home user, one PC, wants a quick answerPC Health CheckMicrosoft's verdict with a short reason
PC fails and you want to fix it yourselfWhyNotWin11Exact values for every requirement
Office with 20 PCsWhyNotWin11Silent mode and CSV export
Checking a used PC in a shopWhyNotWin11Runs from a USB stick without installing
Confirming before upgradingBothFind gaps with WhyNotWin11, confirm with Microsoft's tool
Building a PC before installing WindowsWhyNotWin11Works in Windows PE
PC already on Windows 11WhyNotWin11 with /fuonlyReads feature-update compatibility

Trust and transparency

The two tools earn trust in different ways. PC Health Check is signed by Microsoft and comes from the company that sets the rules. WhyNotWin11 is unsigned in version 2.7.0.0 but publishes its complete source code, so its checks can be inspected line by line. For WhyNotWin11, verifying the SHA-256 of your download takes the place of a signature check.

What neither tool does

It helps to know the limits both tools share, so you do not expect more than they can give.

  • Neither tool changes settings. Enabling the TPM, converting a disk or updating a driver is always your decision and your action.
  • Neither tool guarantees the Windows Update offer timing. Microsoft may roll out upgrades gradually.
  • Neither tool tests application compatibility. Check that your important programs and devices have Windows 11 support from their makers.
  • Neither tool checks your backups. Always back up before making firmware or disk changes.

Keeping these limits in mind, the two tools work well together: one explains, the other confirms.

Reading the PC Health Check result alongside WhyNotWin11

When PC Health Check reports "This PC can't run Windows 11", it usually names one reason first. WhyNotWin11 can then show whether that is the only problem. The pairs below are the most common.

PC Health Check message mentionsCheck these WhyNotWin11 linesUsual next step
The processor is not supportedCPU CompatibilityHardware limit; consider ESU or replacement
TPM 2.0 is a requirementTPM VersionEnable Intel PTT or AMD fTPM in firmware
The PC must support Secure BootSecure Boot, Boot Method, Disk Partition TypeConvert to GPT, switch to UEFI, enable Secure Boot
Storage or memoryStorage Available, RAM InstalledUpgrade parts where possible

Because PC Health Check may highlight only the first problem it finds, fixing that one and checking again can reveal a second. Running WhyNotWin11 first shows the whole list at once, which saves repeated restarts into the firmware.

  1. Run WhyNotWin11 as administrator and note every red line.
  2. Fix the settings-based failures in the safe order: GPT, UEFI, Secure Boot, TPM, graphics driver.
  3. Run WhyNotWin11 again until only hardware limits remain, if any.
  4. Open PC Health Check and select Check now to see Microsoft's verdict.
  5. If both agree the PC is ready, back up and upgrade.

Frequently asked questions

Is WhyNotWin11 more accurate than PC Health Check?

Both read the same requirements. WhyNotWin11 shows more detail and includes graphics; PC Health Check reflects Microsoft's current eligibility rules directly.

Can I install PC Health Check on Windows 11?

PC Health Check is aimed at Windows 10 PCs that may upgrade. On Windows 11, WhyNotWin11's feature-update check is often more useful.

Do I need both?

Not always. For a quick home check, either is fine. For troubleshooting or multiple PCs, WhyNotWin11 adds a lot; for the final confirmation, PC Health Check gives Microsoft's view.

Does either tool change my PC?

No. Both tools read information. Any fix — enabling TPM, converting a disk, updating a driver — is something you do yourself.

Can PC Health Check run in Windows PE?

Microsoft does not document Windows PE support for PC Health Check. WhyNotWin11 supports Windows PE from version 2.7.0.0.

Which tool should I trust if they disagree about the processor?

Treat Microsoft's published processor list as the reference, because Windows Update follows it. Make sure WhyNotWin11 was online and up to date before comparing.

Does either tool send my information anywhere?

WhyNotWin11 shows results locally and writes files only when you export. When online, it downloads updated processor lists and checks for program updates. PC Health Check is covered by Microsoft's privacy statement.

Which tool is faster?

Both finish within seconds on most PCs. WhyNotWin11 starts immediately because nothing is installed, while PC Health Check needs a one-time installation. On PCs where WhyNotWin11 falls back to dxdiag for the graphics check, the run can take a few seconds longer.